November, a dark night as a train heads through the countryside. Halfway through a dark tunnel, a red lights causes the train to briefly slow and then changes to green, letting the train resume its normal speed. An odd occurrence, as there was nobody working in the tunnel that evening and there isn’t a signal in it. But what is even odder is that Sir Wilfred Saxonby, who was sitting in a first class carriage, is found dead, shot by the gun lying on the floor. The carriage is locked, so it was obviously suicide… but no motive can be found.
Enter Inspector Arnold of Scotland Yard, and his crime-solving cohort, Desmond Merrion. Convinced that something is wrong because of the smallest thing – Saxonby’s ticket is missing. But will Arnold’s investigations be able to unmask a cunning murderer?
This is the fifteenth book that Cecil Street aka John Rhode under the pseudonym Miles Burton. In fact it’s the fifteenth in seven years (he actually had sixteen published between 1930 and 1936) along with seventeen under the John Rhode name. Busy boy. It’s an interesting choice to be reprinted by the British Library – I’m really not sure if the BL chose it or it was offered by the traditionally reluctant Street estate.
It’s a different kettle of fish than most Golden Age books that I’ve read. Although we are presented with an impossible crime, the solution is broken down step by step by solid investigation, first the mechanics of the crime and then the who and why (although if anyone reading it can guess the details of the why, I’d be impressed). It’s the tale of an investigation which plays to Street’s strengths in plotting. The characters are bland in the extreme, in particular Merrion who remains a cipher, but by concentrating on the investigation, this weakness can be overlooked. In some ways, the closest in tone that I’ve read is the god-awful Pit-Prop Syndicate by Freeman Wills Crofts – this one is light-years better than that though.
Merrion is pretty annoying though. It seems that Arnold is the one with the ideas at times – you really don’t want your supersleuth, on being presented with the problem, to have an “it’s probably suicide, but I guess I’ll take a look” approach. Show some enthusiasm, man!
The locked room isn’t desperately exciting, by the way. While not at the “Wire Cage” level of silly, one has to wonder if there were easier ways to kill Saxonby.
As I’ve said, inspired by the BL reprints, I’m embarking on a Rhode-A-Thon (follow the hashtag #IReadRhode on twitter) with this as the first. I wonder how this ranks in the quality of Rhode’s books. I’m guessing it’s average – intricate plotting let down by a silly scheme and paper-thin characterisation. Which sounds like I’m having a go, but it’s still a good read that grips the attention throughout. I might come back to this one and say more when I’ve others to compare it to. In the meantime, however, this one is Well Worth A Look.
Death In The Tunnel is out on May 10th from Poisoned Pen Press. For other reviews, do see what Kate and TomCat said about it.
That is so often the case with classic crime, though: there must be easier ways to kill people, but where would we be without all that ingenuity?
LikeLike
I’m not exactly being won over here …
LikeLike
It’s hard to give it an unconditional recommendation. If you like the idea of following a detective solve a complex crime, this is for you, but if you want an endearing human backstory…
LikeLike
I’d settle for a bit of both … 🙂
LikeLike
Yeah. Rhode is a not a writer you read for his human interest stories, but for the investigation and deconstruction of a complex plot. Why not? There are tons of writers, from past and present, who wrote detective stories with a keen eye for characterization. So something that’s almost pure plot (even for a GAD novel) is a nice change. But then again, I love plot-driven detective stories.
By the way, you can probably look forward to a second Miles Burton review before long.
LikeLike
[…] interesting to compare this book to Death In The Tunnel, written under the Miles Burton pseudonym. In that book, the crime was solved step by step as the […]
LikeLike
[…] immediately preceding the impossible Claverton poisoning, but this has much more in common with Death In The Tunnel, written three years later by the same author under his Miles Burton pseudonym – the entire plot […]
LikeLike
[…] is suspected, Dr Priestley/Desmond Merrion sorts it out. It’s a structure that runs through Death In The Tunnel and The Motor Rally Mystery, so it’s a shame that I read this one and the latter nearly back to […]
LikeLike
[…] Death In The Tunnel – Miles Burton (aka John Rhode) […]
LikeLike
[…] few Rhodes, I was coming to the conclusion that he tended to gravitate to a single plot structure. Death In The Tunnel certain follows it, and it’s not the strongest example of it. But as I’ve read more, I’ve […]
LikeLike
[…] far, they’ve published The Secret Of High Eldersham aka The Mystery Of High Eldersham and Death In The Tunnel, namely Desmond Merrion’s first and fourteenth outing. Unfortunately neither shows Rhode (well, […]
LikeLike
[…] concerned about a pattern that seemed to be evolving in his books, namely the overly-complex plot. Death In The Tunnel is a great example of this, where someone goes to ridiculous lengths to set up a crime that nobody […]
LikeLike
[…] which obviously, I’m rather interested in. Interesting that Burton gets the top billing, but as Death In The Tunnel and The Secret Of High Eldersham are available as British Library reprints, it’s not much of a […]
LikeLike
[…] you can get is £68.25 (bargain) with titles ranging from £5 and £6 (Secret of High Eldersham and Death In The Tunnel, thanks to the British Library) up to £384 to Murder In The Coal Hole aka Written In Dust. There […]
LikeLike
[…] require a huge deductive leap to work it out. But at least it’s simpler than the murder method in Death In The Tunnel by the same author, and the murderer is one of the better hidden ones from Rhode – not as clever […]
LikeLike
[…] Review 666 – Death In The Tunnel by Miles Burton […]
LikeLike
[…] From Paddington, John Rhode uses them as both locations for murder – Death On The Boat-Train and Death In The Tunnel – and as murder weapons – Tragedy On The Line and Dead On The Track – and there are many more […]
LikeLike
[…] Crime, Guy Savage at His Futile Preoccupation.…, TomCat at Beneath the Stains of Time, Steve Barge at In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel, Les Blatt at Classic Mysteries, John Cleal at Crime Review, Sergio Angelini at Tipping My Fedora, […]
LikeLike