Where There Was Smoke (1951) by Brian Flynn – a re-read

Donald Finney, a chemist, was presented with a mysterious opportunity for some work. The mysterious Mr Reheboam offers him a fortune – £100 – for a single night’s work. But that is the last night’s work of Finney’s life as he is soon found dead.

The cause of death is far from clear – there are no wounds on his body, but his skin is strangely discoloured – but the strangest thing is what was found on his body. Or to be precise, what was found in his belly button. A strange note with the name of a local police inspector – and a piece of cooked bacon rind…

A quick aside before we get to the review – on the off-chance you are reading this on a site other than classicmystery.blog, be aware that said site is stealing blog posts from across the internet without permission and reposting them without permission. So, if you’re reading it elsewhere, please come across to the actual site. And on the off-chance the bot who scraped my post reads this and gains sentience, please respond to my message telling you to take down my posts. Or shut your whole site down – either suits me.

Well, it’s been a while since I went back to dear old Brian Flynn – you know, that chap who I’ve managed to get thirty-five of his mystery novels reprinted courtesy of Dean Street Press – but I’ve had a bit of a rotten time of it the past few weeks, so I thought I’d look at one of the books that hasn’t been reprinted and that I had less-than-stellar memories of. Although re-reading my review, it would seem that the memory has cheated a tad.

The issue, I suppose, was that it’s not a whodunit at all. As I said the first time I reviewed it, it’s the story of an investigation into a crime. There’s a really impressive section where Bathurst deduces a fair bit of what happened to Finney just from the note found in his navel, and to be honest, the reader could have worked out a chunk of it. But going into it knowing what sort of mystery it is made me appreciate it more.

It’s a “what is going on” story and while it’s a story of its time, it’s not something where the MacGuffin has dated like Conspiracy At Angel. There’s a strong background of post-war austerity – was it really a case that sausages were available but bacon wasn’t? – and the semi-recurring Constable Chatterton has some good lines when sparring with Bathurst and MacMorran.

There’s a slightly odd conclusion where, basically, Bathurst messes up quite a bit, but this is a very interesting read. It’s never going to make a Flynn Top Ten list from me, but it was definitely worth a re-read, and therefore, if you haven’t read it, a read. Shame the only copy that I’ve ever seen for sale is sitting on the sofa next to me… sorry.

3 comments

  1. OK, this piece begs the question: what would make your top ten Flynn list? I’ve only read a couple of dozen (of the 35 DSP have done so far) but I’d be interested…

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.