More Things Impossible: The Second Casebook of Dr Sam Hawthorne by Edward D Hoch

The second collection of the cases of Dr Sam Hawthorne is a significant step-up from the first. That was a high quality set of locked room murders and impossible crimes, but as it detailed the first stories in the series, there was a certain roughness to the stories, which settled down towards the end.

More Things Impossible details the next fifteen of Sam’s cases, and the tone and quality is much more consistently excellent.

Each story is a perfect example of the fair-play mystery. Contained within less than twenty pages, you get the set-up, the clues and the solution to some excellent mysteries without it feeling at all rushed. I’ve said before that Hoch was the master of the short story mystery, and this book collects what I consider to be some of his finest work. He seems to have made a point of devising situations and/or solutions that are new, rather than rehashing old locked room tricks, and while a couple of the solutions are possibly a little contrived, there’s nothing of the standard of some of Carr’s machinations – the gadget involved in the solution of Fatal Descent springs to mind.

Highlights of this collection for me are The Problem of the Revival Tent – a man is stabbed to death in the middle of an empty circus tent with Sam himself being the only suspect; The Problem of the General Store – a twist on The Judas Window involving shotguns; The Problem of the Gypsy Camp – a man dies of a heart attack, only a bullet is found inside his heart during the autopsy and The Problem of the Tin Goose – a barnstorming plane lands safely only for the pilot to be found dead inside the locked cockpit.

I’ve read all of the stories that are in the next collection, but I hope Crippen and Landru hurry the next volume out anyway, as I’ll certainly be granting it pride of place on my shelf. This is an excellent series, and I heartily recommend it to any amateur sleuth.

UPDATE: It’s been out of print for ages, but an ebook version has finally arrived. Hurrah!


  1. I would like to buy this book but cannot afford the book sold on Amazon. Used books starting from $203.00. Any suggestion where else to look for it? Thank you.


    • Blimey. When did this get so expensive? That’s a real tragedy – all I can suggest is that you keep checking ebay or for an affordable one. Also the page, but until it comes back into print, good luck.


Leave a Reply to Siriwan Cummings Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.