From The Dead (2010) by Mark Billingham

One of the points of this blog is to look for what I would consider classic murder mysteries being published today. As such I do need to look away from the hoard of old paperbacks that I’ve obtained from eBay and look at some modern fiction.

From The Dead is the ninth novel by Mark Billingham to feature Tom Thorne, a character who debuted in Sleepyhead in 1991. He’s been played on TV by David Morrissey recently (if you have Sky One) and he’s an interesting protagonist, although I think to get the most of his personal struggles in this and other books, then you should probably start at the beginning of the series.

In this book, a woman who has just been released from jail for arranging the murder of her gangland husband is shocked first by the disappearance of her daughter and then by a photograph of her supposedly dead husband. No secret is made, plot-wise, that the husband is still alive and arranged for someone else to be burned alive instead of him, but there is a general “what is going on” feel to the story – for example, why would anyone send her the photograph – and once the hitman who was hired is killed in prison, it becomes clear that the husband may well have an accomplice doing his dirty work for him.

As a thriller, this is a very good read. There are a number of twists and turns, including a shocking development halfway through the book that I certainly won’t spoil for you. The problem sometimes with thrillers is finding a balance between a surprising outcome and a realistic outcome. Possibly the ending is a little predictable and doesn’t live up to the shock in the middle of the book, but there are still revelations that might catch you out.

As a character study, Thorne continues to be one of the greatest creations in detective fiction – his character is completely believable and you feel invested in him, especially if you’ve followed the series from the start (read it in order, by the way – there are some major events in some books that Billingham cannot help but refer to at times, so if you want to avoid spoilers for some books, in particular The Burning Girl, read it first).

As a mystery…  First of all, to be fair, it’s not intended to be a fair-play mystery. It’s probably completely unfair to judge it on those grounds, but even with my most generous hat on, you’ve probably forgotten who the mystery accomplice is by the time he is revealed. I found myself flicking back in the book to try and find a mention of the character. It seems a shame, as there’s a brief but very clever feint implicating another character who I think would have been a much more interesting reveal, but it probably would derail the main story. I think it’s an inconsequential character because it’s supposed to be an inconsequential character. That’s only a minor quibble though.

Overall, as a thriller, this, while not the best Thorne book, is still recommended, especially if you’ve read the rest. I’d imagine if you’ve read the rest, then you won’t need my recommendation. If you haven’t, then support your local library and go and borrow Sleepyhead, Scaredy Cat and Lazybones. And then keep reading…


  1. I really enjoyed SLEEPYHEAD a few years ago but got distracted and although I bought the next one (SCAREDY CAT?) nevr got round to reading it – I also heard fairly bad thing about the TV version. But I shall get that book out, wherever it is, and give it a go – that’s after I read the Deaver book you recommended as that is now in the post to me apparently!


  2. Never met a fan of John Dickson Carr I didn’t see eye to eye with – especially ones that appreciate the brilliance of the under-appreciated SHE DIED A LADY and TILL DEATH DO US PART!


  3. […] In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel Spoiler Free Reviews of Fair Play Detective Fiction Skip to content HomeAbout the authorEllery QueenPaul DohertyAmerotke, Chief Judge of ThebesHugh CorbettMathilde of WestminsterThe Ancient Rome MysteriesThe Canterbury TalesThe Memoirs of Roger ShallotThe Sorrowful Mysteries of Brother AthelstanSir Henry Merrivale ← There Was An Old Woman by Ellery Queen From The Dead by Mark Billingham → […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.