The Cup of Ghosts by Paul Doherty

England and France, 1307. Mathilde of Westminster, a young woman trained in the healing arts, escapes the persecution of the Templars by Philip IV of France and becomes handmaiden to Philip’s daughter, Isabella, who is promised to Edward II of England. Between these events, Mathilde witnesses the aftermath of a massacre at a house in Paris and soon, as she accompanies Isabella to England, a number of Edward’s closest advisors, sent to mediate the marriage arrangements, begin to die one by one.

On reaching England, Isabella and Mathilde find Edward in conflict with his earls over his favouritism towards Piers Gaveston, and Edward and Philip are at odds over the Templars in England. Meanwhile the deaths continue. With various parties jockeying for power and an assassin on the loose, can Mathilde keep her Templar background a secret and bring the killer to justice?

OK, a digression first. As you will no doubt have noticed, I’m reviewing a lot of Paul Doherty‘s books recently and there will be many more to come. You see, I’m becoming more and more fascinated with this period of history. Basically speaking, in English schools, you’ll learn a) Ancient Egypt, Greece and Rome; b) William the Conqueror; c) The Tudors and Stuarts and d) The First and Second World Wars. If you’re lucky, the Industrial Revolution might crop up. Henry IV to Richard III can be filled in if you know your Shakespeare, but from about 1100 to 1400, some people might mention Magna Carta, but that will be it. Doherty has set three of his series in this gap – Hugh Corbett works for Edward I, Brother Athelstan is in the reign of Richard II and this latest series, Mathilde of Westminster is set, as I said above, in the early reign of Edward II. Pretty much the only thing anyone – including myself – knows about Edward is that he died with a red hot poker inserted where the sun doesn’t shine.

The book, going from the acceptance of the marriage up to the coronation, paints a vivid picture of both life at court at the time, but also gives an idea of the political machinations at work. Doherty weaves this book around a large number of known events, even including a murder that actually happened – well, to be fair, someone died when a pavilion collapsed at the coronation – Doherty makes it into a murder. Not that this is a lecture – in fact a number of things are left undetailed. It would be up to the reader if they want to find out more about the Order of the Templars – you’re told enough, but clearly there is more to learn. It’s also a very personal story as, like the Memoirs of Roger Shallot, this is told in the first person – in fact, it’s the aged Mathilde’s confession. As with Shallot, she does let slip some hints of events to come, but unlike the old rogue, hers are probably true.

As for the mystery, to be honest, there aren’t a lot of clues flying around, but this is one of those novels where the mystery slowly takes shape until resolving itself into a logical conclusion.

So far, there are two more books in this series, and I certainly want to read more about Edward, Isabella and Mathilde. At this point in his reign, Isabella is a faithful wife, but as you may know, she’s the one who arranged Edward’s alleged poker-bottom interface. I’m looking forward to discovering how that state of affairs arises, but I also hope Doherty takes his time telling the story. This is a marvellous book – not the best mystery I’ve ever read, but a great book nonetheless.

Oh, I should mention, there’s a locked room murder in here too. Not a bad one, at that.


    • And why continue apologizing for a transgression that isn’t even weighing down your conscience or plaguing you with an all-consuming guilt, right? 😉

      I still haven’t entirely made up my mind about Paul Dohery and his merits as a mystery writer. There’s definitely a lot to like in his books, such as his obvious love for history and locked room mysteries, but I have yet to read a story whose resolution blows me away – i.e. his magnum opus. But then again, I’m only two novels in and a third ready to be read.


      • I do take your point about the quality of the mystery – the clueing can be minimal and it is sometimes a little hard to focus on the actual problem at hand with the various politics vying for attention. So far, I’d rate The White Rose Murders and The Nightingale Gallery as the best for me so far – and by best, I mean very good indeed – maybe Corpse Candle as well.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.