Fortune Like The Moon by Alys Clare

Another trip to medieval England – this time, we’re off to Kent, 1189, just as Richard the (future) Lionheart has become King of England. Richard, due to concern about his popularity, has the astoundingly ill-advised scheme to appease the population by ordering the release of every prisoner in the country. When a nun is found apparently raped and murdered near Hawkenlye Abbey, Richard sends Josse D’Acquin to investigate – and to try and remove any blame from Richard. Along with the Abbess Helewise, he investigates, but it takes a second death before the truth becomes apparent.

Michael Jecks, author of The Tolls of Death, popped over to comment on my review of The Sanctuary Seeker, mentioning the challenge of dropping partway into a series of books, so I’m doing my best to read series in order. This is the first of (currently) thirteen books featuring D’Acquin and Helewise (not the easiest crime-fighting duo to pronounce), known, at least on the cover, as The Hawkenlye Mysteries. To be honest, I’d never heard of them, or Alys Clare, but came upon this one while trolling the local library.

So, a lucky find or not?

The opening book of a series has to get the introductions out of the way, and sometimes that can make the book suffer, leaving less room for a decent plot – which, as you may know, is the primary thing that I look for. Alys Clare does a pretty good job of making a decent introduction without it going on for too long – focussing on Josse first of all, and then, to a slightly lesser extent on the Abbess. It’s a slightly odd balance – most of the chapters are from one or the others point of view, and I’d have preferred a little more from the Abbess, but as she is confined, practically, to the abbey and Josse is free to visit suspects away from the abbey, it does make logical sense.

It’s a nice little mystery, to be fair. Nothing particularly complicated, but there’s a nice bit of misdirection. The purists might moan a little that some critical characters take an age to actually show up – but it doesn’t feel like it’s treading water at any point. The characters are well-written, especially some of the supporting characters. The plot is work-outable, for the most part, but there are still some surprises along the way. There’s a real intent to do something clever with the plot and Clare nearly pulls it off. The ultimate culprit is signposted a little early for my liking, and a crucial plot item probably needed a bit more indication before its importance is revealed, but I did like very much that despite getting the larger share of the action, Josse gets it wrong and the Abbess gets it right.

So, an enjoyable book all round. Definitely going to look out for the next one in the series.


  1. New author for me too, thanks very much for doing all this scouting amongst historical mysteries – amazing how much of worth is out there still waiting to be read. I’ll just get out my TARDIS and buy some extra time to do all the reading I need …


    • I’ll be taking a little historical break – unless my copy of Bloodstone arrives today – as I’ve ordered the first in the series for both Peter Tremayne and Susanna Gregory. Going to find something a little more modern in the meantime – maybe finally read that Bryant and May book that’s been “Coming Soon” for about two months…


  2. Synchronicity strikes again. I was going to ask about Susanna Gregory and if you planned to read any of her books. I met her at Bouchercon Chicago in 2006 and she was quietly charming and truly interested in the old book I was selling. She impressed me enough to track down a few of her MAtthe artholomew books but…that’s right…I have yet to read one.

    Speaking of TARDIS, Sergio and Steve, check this out. Wish it were a real TARDIS with the spatial paradox. It would be a very welcome addition to my book crammed condo.


    • Pretty sure Mrs Puzzledoctor would say no to the TARDIS…

      The first Matthew Barthelomew is on its way, so review coming soon. But my copy of Bloodstone arrived today – the new Athelstan. Not sure I can resist that…


    • That bookcase is just fabulous – thanks John, truly put a smile all over my face – I am definitely sending that link around (and the putative Mrs Fedora would just have to put up with it).

      Cheers mate,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.