Mini-Reviews – The Burglar In The Closet, Blood Line, The Maze of Cadiz & An Expert In Murder

As I mentioned in my last review, I’ve a bit of a backlog of books to review and as such, I’m going to post a few digest reviews for some titles – not because they’re particularly undeserving, more that I’ve forgotten too many details about them due to the other holiday reading that may have got slightly out of control – eleven books in a week.

So, here are mini-reviews of:

  • The Burglar In The Closet by Lawrence Block
  • Blood Line by Alanna Knight
  • The Maze of Cadiz by Aly Monroe
  • An Expert In Murder by Nicola Upson

Off we go!

The Burglar In The Closet by Lawrence Block

The second in the series featuring Bernie Rhodenbarr, the gentleman burglar of New York. Bernie is asked by his dentist to steal back some jewellery that was lost in his divorce settlement. Unfortunately, she returns early and Bernie gets locked in her wardrobe. Even more unfortunately, while trying to extricate himself, the ex-wife is murdered in the other room. As the dentist is the chief suspect, he offers the police a viable alternative suspect – namely Bernie himself…

This is a fun quick read – as with the previous book, Burglars Can’t Be Choosers, Bernie is an entertaining narrator. The plot keeps moving itself forward and, at the end of the day, forms itself into an enjoyable little mystery. This is available on Kindle as part of a collection of the first five Burglar novels – a recommended purchase.

Blood Line by Alanna Knight

Another Kindle recommendation, the majority of this series featuring the Edinburgh Victorian detective, Inspector Faro, is available for less than a pound each. In this second book, Faro investigates some mysterious deaths at the castle, including, from years previous, his own father. The deaths somehow seem tied into a secret that dates back to Mary Stewart and James VI themselves.

Another enjoyable straightforward tale – as with the first in the series, Enter Second Murderer, there’s a romance for the Inspector as well – a trend that might get a bit tiresome if it’s in every book in the series – and, to be fair, as the book goes on, you’d have to be a bit slow not to see where it’s going in terms of the villain of the piece. What is disappointing is the somewhat unsatisfactory nature of the ending – not the mystery, but the aftermath – and I hope that it is expanded on in the next book. Otherwise, Faro seems a bit of a wimp. Still, it’s a decent enough read –  certainly value for money.

The Maze of Cadiz by Aly Monroe

Bought on the strength of the Spanish connection and Aly Monroe’s recent winning of the CWA Historical Dagger for Icelight, this involves spy Peter Cotton being sent to Cadiz in 1944 to relieve the local agent and then close the bureau. When he gets there, he finds that the agent is dead and sets about investigating.

Not my cup of tea, really, I’m afraid. The evocation of war-time Cadiz is well done and there’s some good history here. But I found the narrative a bit plodding – not an awful lot happens and a lot of it is irrelevant to the main plot. Which is, of course, a lot like real life would be, but not really my thing in a novel. It’s partially that this is a spy novel first and a mystery second, and the mystery is my preferred reading.

An Expert In Murder by Nicola Upson

The playwright and mystery novelist Josephine Tey (most famous for The Daughter of Time) is in London for the closing of her play Richard of Bordeaux. Soon the young woman she befriends on the train journey from Edinburgh is found murdered in her train carriage, and another death follows soon. As she, and her policeman friend, investigate, secrets emerge amongst the cast of the play.

I have to admit, I find the idea of writing a book featuring a version of a real person who may well have relatives that remember her – she died sixty years ago – a little odd – Tey, you see, was a pseudonym, so it’s not the “real” Tey, so to speak. Having said that, it’s nowhere near as disturbing as I found another novel that features the return of a real serial killer from as recently as 1969. Very bad taste, I thought. But that’s a different writer and, literally, another story.

Back to this one, and it’s another enjoyable read. The main characters do rather trip over the solution at the end – the policeman finds a really signpost-y clue and Tey walks in on the murderer trying to kill someone – but it’s a lot of fun, a fast-moving plot with a decent period setting.

I’d say of these four series, it will be Nicola Upson that I’ll be returning to first and Aly Monroe that I’ll probably avoid in the future, prize or no prize.

Back to full reviews in two posts time, but next, it’s my 250th post. Blimey.


  1. Glad to see Upson get the nod from you. I have enjoyed the two books from the series that I’ve read (this one and Angel with Two Faces). Two for Sorrow is on the TBR list, but there are too many in front of it right now. I read Enter Second Murderer quite a while ago…all I remember about it is being unimpressed and uninspired to try any more Knight books. I can’t decide if your mini-view changes that or not…..


    • I’ll only go for book three because I enjoyed book one more, if you see what I mean. The more I think of it, the more the ending of Blood Line really annoyed me.

      Looking forward to the next Upson book – I feel a bit bad that I had to do a mini-review of it, rather than a whole post, but there is only so much time in the world…


  2. […] In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel Spoiler Free Reviews of Fair Play Detective Fiction Skip to content HomePaul DohertyHugh CorbettThe Sorrowful Mysteries of Brother AthelstanAmerotke, Chief Judge of ThebesThe Journals of Roger ShallotThe Canterbury TalesThe Ancient Rome MysteriesMathilde of WestminsterAlexander The GreatKathryn SwinbrookeOther Historical MysteriesAlys ClareAriana FranklinSteve HockensmithMichael JecksBernard KnightPeter TremayneSir Henry MerrivaleClassic BibliographiesAgatha ChristieEllery QueenSherlock HolmesChallenges2012 ChallengesThe Mystery Tour of the USAThe Author ← Mini-Reviews – The Burglar In The Closet, Blood Line, The Maze of Cadiz & An Expert… […]


  3. I missed this post back in the summer. I want to read all of these series. The Burglar series would be a re-read, at least for the early ones. I like the idea of mini-reviews. I haven’t found myself able to be that brief.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.