Happy Brian Flynn Day!

Happy Brian Flynn Day!

Yes, it’s finally here. Today’s the day that the first ten Anthony Bathurst mystery novels are finally back in print, for the first time in most cases in nearly ninety years. It’s been 1000 days, give or take, since I first reviewed a book by Brian Flynn, the unfairly-forgotten classic The Mystery Of The Peacock’s Eye, and probably about 999 days since I started bugging the British Library and Dean Street Press about him.

Thankfully, the BL ignored me, otherwise we’d probably only be looking at the one title, but eventually Dean Street Press saw the light/decided the easiest way to shut me up was to reprint them (delete as applicable).


Just in case anyone thinks my constant banging on about the books is advertising, it’s really not – I’m not getting paid for this. For me, this is a labour of love, nothing more. Of all the obscure authors that I’ve come across, Brian Flynn is the one that I most wanted other people to be able to read. It’s hard to put my finger exactly on what made me push so hard to get Brian back into print.

In part, it’s because after too many years blogging, I was looking to do something in the field beyond blethering on about how great/terrible books were. Also, though, it was the fact that there are few authors who I enjoy reading as much as Brian, and yet other, less enjoyable authors were the ones who were being reprinted.

By less enjoyable, I mean in relative terms. In my opinion, though, The Mystery Of The Peacock’s Eye, The Murders Near Mapleton and The Creeping Jenny Mystery stand head and shoulders above most of the reprints out there, and the other seven titles aren’t far behind. Fans of realism in crime fiction might struggle with a few bits and bobs, but they’d struggle with Dame Agatha, John Dickson Carr and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle too, so Brian’s in good company.

So I’d like to thank some people for helping to make this happen – my sister-in-law, Susie, for buying me The Mystery Of The Peacock’s Eye in the first place, my wife, Professor Puzzle Doctor (she’s had a promotion) for tracing Brian’s heirs, Brian’s family for all their help with the introductions and for The Triple Bite, and, of course, Dean Street Press who have done a stunning job with the books. The physical books are things of beauty and using the original cover images, where possible, is a great touch. Their dedication to putting these out as accurately as possible is amazing – even to the extent of correcting an obscure typo in the US version of The Case Of The Black Twenty-Two.

So, I do hope you give Brian a go – I’d recommend starting with The Mystery Of The Peacock’s Eye and then heading back to the beginning. There is an element of continuity throughout the books – Brian has a habit of referring back to earlier cases, although never spoiling those books – so reading them in order adds a smidge of something, but it’s by no means essential.

And to answer a question that I’ve been asked a few times – will there be more reprints after these? Well, it depends on how well these do. So if you enjoy them, tell your friends – to be precise, tell your friends to buy them too. I would love to see the entire canon back in print – if nothing else, it’ll save me a fortune tracking down the books that I haven’t got. Oh, and if you know someone with a copy of The Edge Of Terror or The League of Matthias that we can borrow to source the text from, do let me know…


And finally, for those extra special readers who have put up with me over the years banging the drum, here is an exclusive extra!


Yes, that is the actual chair that Brian sat in when writing his books. Honest! See, you don’t get that sort of bonus content every day!


  1. This is really very cool PD. And even if I end up not liking Flynn, thanks for the effort on my behalf. And as a reader of GAD, the effort really was on my behalf.


  2. Well, the books were released in India around 4 and a half hours early due to the time difference, and the set has been purchased and I spent nearly half night awake reading Black 22 (I have previously read Billiard room and peacock’s eye from this set). Thanks a lot for getting him back on print.


    • Barzun has a lot to answer for! But as I’ve said before, suppose you hadn’t heard of Christie before, decided to try a book and picked up The Big Four… Would you give her a second chance?


  3. Thankfully, the BL ignored me, otherwise we’d probably only be looking at the one title, but eventually Dean Street Press saw the light/decided the easiest way to shut me up was to reprint them.

    We’re proud of you and, if your badgering included any blackmail, we’ll be your character witnesses in court. My reviews will be coming in the weeks/month ahead and bought the missing titles today.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Hi, I don’t comment here often but I’ve been reading your blog for a while. I bought the first 4 Brian Flynn mysteries after reading this post about them. I’ve started reading The Mystery of The Peacock’s Eye and I love it so far! It’s exactly how I expect a classic Golden Age mystery to be! Thank you so much for doing the good work for us Golden Age mystery enthusiasts and keep up all your hard work. I appreciate everything you do so much!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.