“Either Sir Oswin Bassingham – war hero, general and right-hand man to the King – attacked Price Prospero, ran downstairs when discovered, and vanished in a puff of smoke only to reappear elsewhere and then seal himself in the privy and commit suicide in, we presume, regret – forgetting in his distress that he had been left-handed his entire life – or the plague which has trapped us here took on a physical form to enact a vendetta against the Prince for reasons unknown, and is able to stalk us through stone walls while strangling some of us, stabbing others and slitting the wrists of yet others behind sealed doors for reasons we are yet to discover.”
Yes, that just about sums it up nicely. Authors can be so helpful sometimes…
It was an odd feeling that I got when I discovered that Jim Noy, he of The Invisible Event blog, had produced his first mystery novel. First of all, I was delighted that my friend’s labour of love had finally seen fruition. Then there was a very brief panic that now my followers are going to expect me to write something. And then there was a genuine feeling of panic that, as I’m duty bound by my solemn blogging vows to review every mystery novel that I read – what if it wasn’t very good?
Luckily, that wasn’t a problem at all – far from it.
It’s hard to find an exact comparison with something in the existing genre for the book. Clearly inspired by Jim’s love of locked room mysteries – there are three (arguably four) impossible crimes here – and complete with a Challenge To The Reader, along with a number of false solutions spread throughout… but it’s hard to think of a Golden Age mystery that is a reimagining of a classic gothic tale, in this case, as one might guess from the title, Edgar Allen Poe’s The Masque Of The Red Death.
I’ve not read that book – I think I watched the Vincent Price film once upon a time, but I don’t remember much about it and it didn’t inspire me to read the short story. Happily, there’s no need to know anything about that story – basically there’s a plague keeping everyone inside the castle. The incidents in the mystery echo some of the main beats but it doesn’t hurt it at all if you don’t know what those beats are.
Setting what is to an extent an historical mystery – so no fingerprints or DNA for example – in a fictional world helps as well as the backstory and motivations can be tailored to fit the story. Jim’s world-building here is impressive as the reader gets a clear picture of what is going on in the background without it being delivered in solid chunks of unsubtle exposition.
On to the story, and it’s told from the perspective of the young servant Thomas, who acts as the Watson (albeit a much smarter Watson) to Sir William Collingwood, who acts as the sleuth for the story. Thomas is a good point of view character, as he is allowed deductions, both false and true, of his own, while being swept up in the events himself as he becomes more involved in the machinations taking part within the castle’s walls.
The mystery is an intriguing one, with Jim doing a good job of juggling a small cast of suspects. One of the locked room solutions is rather technical, so he wisely reveals this before the finale as I don’t think it’s something that could reasonably be deduced by the reader. You could make the same criticism, to be honest, about the details of the solution of the primary murder – the one with the goblet – but while it seems unlikely to be feasible, it should be noted that there is enough to spot that the killer did… something and Jim does thank a medical professional in his afterword, so pretty sure that it is possible.
This is a very impressed debut novel and an engrossing read. Perhaps the killer’s ability to produce such a complex plan so quickly is questionable – as in the case of a lot of classic crime novels – and perhaps there is one too many fake-outs after the Challenge to the Reader… oh, and it completely fails the Bechdel test, but this are minor quibbles. I would strongly recommend this book to any mystery fan – something familiar and quite different at the same time, told with an impressive confidence from a debut author. Any publishing house out there who reads this, I strongly suggest you get in touch with Jim, as I’m sure book two, whatever shape it may take, will be just as impressive.
The Red Death Murders is available now from Amazon and other booksellers (I presume).
I got the paper edition at the weekend and have just started reading. Are there many examples of a locked room murder in the loo? Don’t think Carr quite managed that feat. Jim pretty much had me smiling from ear to ear right from there 😁
I know of one locked toilet murder, but it’s not the same as this one.
The 45 Steps by Peter Crowther is a short story which also features someone getting bumped off on the bog. I liked that story’s weird humour and strangeness.
I’m not going out of my way to say hearing the book has toilet murder in has made me more eager to read it, but, well, I did click on the review pretty fast after reading Puzzle Doctor’s tweet I guess.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I found the solution to the toilet murder so complicated and convoluted that I could not make head or tail of it !
Thanks, Doc, I really appreciate this.
You’re right about that technical locked room — I could find no way to provide one piece of information without it being Obviously Very Relevant, so I decided to withhold it and just reason through the solution in the next chapter. Plus, I hope there are enough indications of other shenanigans to make it clear that something is up…
Hilarious that you should mention the Bechdel Test, though. Let me explain:
When I told a friend about the setup of this, his first comment was a wry “Oh, so you’ll fail the Bechdel test” (for anyone who doesn’t know, passing the Bechdel Test requires two female characters to have a conversation about something other than a male character who is not present — since there are only men in the castle, this couldn’t happen). I therefore promised him that I’d fail it in reverse, too, and have two men discuss a female character who is not present — arguably this happens twice, the most notable example coming at the start of chapter 19.
It’s just hilarious to me that you’ve picked up on what is essentially an in-joke. What are the odds? 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have just finished the book. The solution to the goblet murder is quite all right and feasible.
However, I did not enjoy the book as much as you did . I found it too complicated for my taste.
It sounds intriguing. The price is reasonable, so I will give it a shot.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad I tried it, I liked it. I look forward to future books. Whether with same character/settings or otherwise. I do think maps should be included however!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Read it over three days. Perhaps there was too much going on for a single book, long as it was. A bit of an everything-but-the-kitchen-sink approach and not enough time for the story (nor the reader) to breathe between key events. Also too many ”no u” style convolutions come the end. I think this is best approached as one where the reader is just along for the ride.
Still, I had to admire the zeal and genre savvy on show. The setting drew me in, the suspects were more than cardboard cut outs and the impossibilities were great, one very reminiscent of the “The Mystery of the Yellow Room”; another which might rival the “The Honjin Murders” in how madly mechanical it is. It definitely reads like a love letter to the locked room mystery and its leading lights. All things considered, a promising debut.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks for giving it a fair go. It’s doubtless a little overstuffed, probably just me getting carried away in case I didn’t get to write another one 🙂
Really delighted that the setting and the people drew you in, and that you enjoyed the impossibilities — it was loads of fun devising the plot to bring them all together. This is undoubtedly my love letter to the genre, and I’m thrilled that people are finding things to enjoy in it.
I intend to read JJ’s shenanigans sooner or later. Not gonna lie, after learning about the page count, the historical topic and seeing the cover, I immediately thought of a scandinoir social mystery with locked room tricks sprinkled in. I mean…caligraphic font plus sans serif. It’s a ballsy move, I give him that. I’m glad to hear that, though a bit mechanical in places, it respects the grand tradition. As Borges once said, If you write for today you take the role of a journalist, and as we all know, newspapers are disposable. Here’s hoping he keeps on writing!
LikeLiked by 2 people
[…] Red Death Murders has been reviewed, among others, by Steve Barge at In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel, James Scott Byrnside, Brad Friedman at Ah Sweet Mystery Blog, TomCat at Beneath the Stains of […]