The Dog Sitter Detective Plays Dead by Antony Johnston

Lights! Camera! Action! Filming has begun at Hendale Hall in Yorkshire on Draculania, a gender-switched version of Dracula. The venue has been chosen because of the hall has a legend of its own vampire, an ancestor of the current Lord of the manor. But as the mist draws in, there seems to be something lurking out there in the fog… Can the Hensdale vampire be real?

Gwinny Tuffel is balancing dog-sitting a Jack Russell for an aging actor friend and playing Dr Jacqueline Seward in the film, but when the actor playing Luke Westenera is found stabbed through the heart with a prop stake while locked inside a trailer – locked from the inside, obviously – it falls to her to track down a flesh and blood killer. Admittedly, a flesh and blood killer who can apparently walk through walls…

Definitely wearing the “In Search Of…” part of the blog title at the moment, and those lovely people at Allison & Busby have auto-approved me on NetGalley so I thought I’d check out this one, the third Dogsitter Detective title.

I’ll be honest, I thought I was just going to get a simple cosy read out of this one. I had a train journey that I wanted to pass quickly and as I knew the train back would inevitably be populated by football fans, I thought this would be an ideal time-filler. It wasn’t, though. It was a really engrossing read, a clever mystery and a load of fun. Far more than what I expected, and it did an excellent job of distracting me from some over-excited Watford supporters – bless them, they don’t win that often.

Similar to the Rosemary Shrager books, the author here knows how to construct a mystery. A relatively small number of suspects (plus a few orbiting the plot who just might have something to do with it), an intriguing set-up, a sleuth who you enjoy spending time with, and there are clues as well.

And I’m a bit cross/happy about this one because I saw the crucial thing. I even considered the crucial thing. And then forgot about it with the other shenanigans going on. I was genuinely caught out by the murderer – it’s been a while (EDIT: oh, hang on, Thorogood did it too. Whoops!) so I was both surprised and impressed by this one. The locked room is pretty simple, but clever enough to fool people (i.e. me) and not only is the method clued, there’s a reason for it!

And the dog. I should say that I despise Jack Russell’s, as one bit me on the way to my own birthday party when I was 9ish, nasty yappy things, but Lily is the exception to the rule. Especially as she does contribute something to the plot, providing an interesting clue.

The setting is well done, the suspects are fun, Draculina is a plausible idea that isn’t played for laughs (although there are some good lines peppered throughout the dialogue) – all in all, it’s pretty convincing.

A really pleasant surprise, this one, and I’ll be taking the other two books out for a walk once I get my hands on some copies. Don’t be put off by the cosy title (which doesn’t make sense as Seward is very much alive), this is a well-constructed mystery that is well worth your time.

The Dog Sitter Detective Plays Dead is out this Thursday from Allison & Busby. Many thanks for the review e-copy.

5 comments

  1. I had the pleasure of moderating a Crimefest panel with Antony Johnston and read the first book in the series. It was an excellent book and he was a terrific panelist – the sort who makes a moderators life very easy by pertinent, intelligent contributions

    Like

    • I’m really looking forward to going back to the first two books. It’s almost a shame it has such a “cosy” vibe as I think a lot of mystery readers might well pass on it for that reason. I guess that’s why I’m here – to inform and educate 😉

      Like

  2. Based on your review, I got the first book in the series. Enjoyed it to the extent I got the others, and so far they’re living up to expectations. Same has been true of the Three Dahlias, another one of your suggestions I followed up on.

    Like

    • Thanks for letting me know. Always nice to get some confirmation that I wasn’t imagining how good a book was. I know sometimes I can be more forgiving depending on what sort of mood I’m in so glad to know I’m not alone in enjoying these. Glad to have helped with the recommendations.

      Like

Leave a reply to #1264: A Little Help for My Friends – Finding a Modern Locked Room Mystery for TomCat Attempt #27: The Dog Sitter Detective Plays Dead (2025) by Antony Johnston | The Invisible Event Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.