Doc On The Box – The Residence

A B Wynter, the Chief Usher of the White House, is lying dead in the game room. Having taken poison and cut his wrists, with a suicide note in his pocket, it’s a clear case of suicide. Well, that would be the easy answer, especially as there is a formal White House dinner honouring the Australian Prime Minister at the time. The President’s Chief Advisor is very keen on the suicide theory. But Cordelia Cupp, the greatest detective in the world, thinks differently.

There is a slight problem though. The administration want it ruled as a suicide. Otherwise the house has 132 rooms to search and 157 suspects that need to be kept on site, including representatives from a foreign government. That’s not the problem – the problem the administration has is, as I said, named Cordelia Cupp…

The latest Netflix murder mystery, an eight-part series starring Uzo Aduba as Cordelia Cupp and a cast of thousands (well, a bit less than that) as the White House staff and guests. And Kylie Minogue as herself.

Weirdly, the show is based on a non-fiction book, The Residence: Inside the Private World of the White House by Kate Anderson Bower. No, it’s not a story of an actual murder in the White House, something inspired the creators to take this book and add a murder mystery plot on top of it. And a murder mystery plot with style, panache, humour and even a cluefinder!

This was such a treat. To be fair, I thought episodes 2 and 3 dragged a little, but we were being shown quite a lot of important information as the story settles into place, and the killer is a bit guessable. But those are the only negatives – and there are so many positives.

The scriptwriters clearly know their murder mysteries – the titles of the episodes are all classic mystery titles from literature and TV, and they aren’t all that well known – The Mystery Of The Yellow Room, for example. I mentioned the clue-finder because every revelation that Cordelia explains, we see the little clip from earlier in the show that we completely missed as being important. Everything! And the solution is both delightfully complex and still perfectly followable.

Basically, the style is very influenced by Knives Out! which isn’t a bad thing in my book. The cast is perfect – it’s a shame that we didn’t get the original A B Wynter, namely Andre Braugher, who passed away during filming, but Giancarlo Esposito does a great job as the complex victim (who’s name was, I presume, changed in tribute to Braugher).

I could go on, but there are two other highlights that I wanted to mention. The first is the rather subtle love story that comes to the fore in episode seven, and the second is an exchange that should be immortalised in crime fiction communities forever.

When the White House advisor Harry Hollinger (Ken Marino) speculates that it’s a Murder On The Orient Express solution, and asks Chief of Police Dokes (Isiah Whitlock Jr) which film version he preferred, the response – “Neither. I read the book” while waving what looked to me like a first edition sans-DJ – was absolutely priceless.

All in all, a hugely enjoyable show – do press on if you find the first couple of episodes being, plot-wise at least, mostly set-up. Uzo Aduba is absolutely fantastic as Cordelia and let’s hope we see more of her in the future.

5 comments

  1. Glad you are having fun BUT just wanted to mention ever since I finished the new season of Death in Paradise I have been (admittedly rather impatiently) watching this space awaiting your review…

    Like

  2. I hadn’t heard of this show before reading about it from you, but I’ve just started watching and it seems brilliant so far! A bit jarring to see Al Franken as a Senator again, but we live in strange times…

    By the way, have you seen The Afterparty on Apple TV yet? I don’t want to say too much about it other than that it’s another recent murder mystery series, but I feel like if you enjoyed The Residence, you’d enjoy that too. 

    Like

      • There are a couple gems on there like Severance and Ted Lasso, but I’m always surprised how few classic murder mystery fans know about The Afterparty! Worth subscribing even just for a month or two to watch. There are two seasons (unfortunately it’s been canceled since), each with an overarching mystery, and the central conceit is that you get a Rashomon/Five Little Pigs-style narrative where each episode is a flashback told from one character’s perspective, but in the style of a different movie genre (e.g. rom com, action, horror, musical) depending on the character’s worldview. Loads of fun and really creative use of the medium.

        I’ve now binged the whole of The Residence, and it was really quite splendid! Great balance of humor and pathos, beautifully diverse casting, a lead detective with the perfect amount of quirkiness and pluck, and a really lovely homage to the classic above stairs/below stairs mystery subgenre. You call it “weird,” and it is, but it’s also a truly inspired choice to read a nonfiction account of the White House Residence Staff and realize the best way to explore that kind of grand domestic drama is through a murder.

        The preponderance of interesting side plots substantial enough beyond mere filler (and, frankly, were just so darn funny) kept the momentum from ever falling flat. They also very satisfyingly addressed the classic “why would one place have so many likely murderers” question by really selling the setting as such a pressure cooker of a workplace that more than a few different suspects would snap.

        As for the clueing, hopefully this is vague enough not to spoil but clear enough to understand: while I’d worked out the overarching reason why the case was so confusing to solve, I didn’t catch on to the related reason for why the killer was acting a certain way, and I thought that bit was very clever in hindsight. 

        I do think there’s a bit of a trend in recent Knives Out-esque whodunnits where you can guess the murderer by working out what grand thematic message the author’s trying to convey and which reveal would tie the neatest bow around said message, but The Residence still managed to make me doubt myself. 

        Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.