The Murders Of Christmas Past (2026) by Andreina Cordani

Two years ago, Ebeneezer Scrooge was visited by three ghosts who convinced him to change his miserly ways.

One year ago, a new spirit arrived, the ghost of a murdered woman caused Scrooge to risk his new life to find her murderer.

And now, as Christmas comes around again, more spirits have come to Scrooge to find justice for them. A burned man, a silent, angry spirit, follows him everywhere, but when one of his old business rivals, Fustian Brittle, is murdered, it seems that someone is targeting Christmas-hating misers, a killer that seems to walk through walls.

But things are hardly as simple as finding a flesh and blood killer. Because Scrooge saw Brittle before he died, in the company of someone who could indeed walk through walls. The Spirit Of Christmas Present himself. And the victim had a paper crown on his head…

My first Christmas mystery of the year – there will be more to come. I know some people turn their nose up at the Christmas cash-in, and in some cases, I agree. Certainly a few novellas, spin-offs of existing series, that I’ve read were, quite frankly, poor, especially as mysteries. But there are Christmas mysteries out there that are genuinely well-mysteries that the humbug-lovers out there will over look.

And then there are the Scrooge mysteries by Andreina Cordani. Which are far more than just well-constructed mysteries.

There’s so much to enjoy here. I’m not a Dickens fan, far from it, but the world that he and Andreina have built here is marvellous. Scrooge comes across as a genuinely sympathetic character, but with real flaws, such as not noticing the danger that Tim is exposing himself to, in order to help the old man. Marley, still bound to the earth, adds an extra dimension, both to Scrooge’s past and his own, much more nefarious deeds. He adds a much more cynical voice to proceedings in his sections. All the characters – Scrooge, Tim, Mrs Tassell, Marley, Bob – have their own story arcs and Andreina wisely paces things so that there are still stories to tell as the series goes on. I’ve mentioned “second book syndrome” a couple of times before, where a series struggles because it resolved all the personal issues in Book One. This is most definitely not the case here. By the end of the tale, Scrooge may have moved a little further down the road to redemption, but there’s still a way to go, and some inevitable wrong turns to be made.

The mystery itself is a multi-layered affair, with the big picture slowly being revealed at a perfect pace. I should say that if you’re only here for the locked room bit, then you’ll be disappointed, but that’s not the point of the book at all. It’s a gripping mystery tale, with characters you want to read about… oh, and one other thing? It’s actually Christmassy. Very, very Christmassy…

I can’t recommend A Scrooge Mystery and this one highly enough – or anything else that Andreina has written, come to think of it. A Scrooge Mystery was a gnat’s whisker away from the Grand Puzzly last year, and this one is just as good. If not better.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.