Dove Amongst The Hawks by Paul Doherty

Dove Amongst The HawksAugust 1477, and the physician Luke Chichele is “invited” by King Edward IV to join a royal commission to investigate the death of his predecessor, King Henry VI. Henry was always reputed to be a weak ruler, and was the cause of the outbreak of the War of the Roses, a country-wide conflict which lead to Henry’s deposition by Edward. Shortly afterwards, Henry, confined to the Tower of London, mysteriously died. But now there is a claim that miracles are occurring at Henry’s tomb and Rome wishes the dead king to be beatified. Edward is keen to prevent that, hence the investigation into Henry’s life… and death.

No sooner has the investigation begun and tasks assigned, when one of their number is found dead, throttled and left floating in his fish-pond. It seems that someone is stalking Luke and his fellow investigators – someone who knows the truth about the death of a King and will stop at nothing to keep it buried… And with people like Edward, the Duke of Clarence and a certain Duke of Gloucester – the future Richard III – Luke soon realises that there is no-one that he can trust…

A recently re-released early work from Paul Doherty, this is a non-series element in a similar vein to The Death Of A King, The Whyte Harte or the recent The Last Of Days – an investigation by a fictitious character into a real historical mystery. But there’s something different about this one…

First of all, this seemed to be a timely read. The White Queen, the story of Elizabeth Woodville, Edward IV’s queen, is currently showing on BBC1, an adaptation of the Philippa Gregory novel. I’ll be fair, I’ve not watched it, but the press coverage seems to imply lots of heaving bosoms, soft-focus rumpy-pumpy and some dubious historical accuracy. Not really my cup of mead.

Woodville takes an important role in this story too, showing herself to be just as powerful as her husband. Basically the whole family – Clarence, Gloucester and Edward seem to be on the verge of throttling each other while she pulls the strings. As a snapshot of the time, it’s an intriguing picture and, as ever, it seems that Paul has constructed a plot structured around a number of true occurrences at the time.

The difference I mentioned to those other non-series books? It’s also a proper murder mystery as well, capable of sitting alongside the Corbett and Athelstan series. It is completely fairly clued, both for the murder of the king and the present-day murders and on top of that, it’s bloody clever. I’m going to say no more than that for fear of spoilers.

So… obviously, you know I’m going to praise one of Paul’s books, but this one has edged its way into my Top Five. One of Paul’s finest works, out of print for far too long and now available as an ebook. The Highest Recommendation.


A public service announcement now. Obviously, dear reader, you’re already reaching for mouse to head to Amazon (other ebook providers are available) to buy this or something else by Paul Doherty. Be warned if you, like me, tend to hit the “sort by price, lowest first” button after searching. The recently published ebook “Shielded Spirit – Chronicles of a Lion by Paul Doherty” is not by the Paul Doherty that I constantly review here but by someone else who shares the same name. I know nothing about the book, but do proceed with caution if you’re looking for a mystery. If you want something cheap, then I recommend the short stories that Paul has posted – my favourite is The Murder of Innocence, but there are a couple of Athelstan and an Amerotke there as well.


  1. […] Other than this, Richard’s time on the throne was murder-free, if you don’t count his own possible-murder on the order of his deposer, Henry IV. But despite much research, there seems to be little to recount concerning the reign of Henry and his two sons, imaginatively called Henry and Henry. It is only when Henry VI, having conclusively lost the Hundred Years War, was deposed by Edward IV in 1461 that murder seemed to return to the land. Little is known so far about the 22 cases involving the peddler Roger the Chapman as detailed by Kate Sedley, but there has been extensive research into the activities in Canterbury of Kathryn Swinbrooke, as detailed by C L Grace aka Paul Doherty. Note that some suspicions have been raised around the fate of Henry VI. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.