Wicked Autumn by G M Malliet

Wicked AutumnNether Monkslip, a quiet leafy village in England, on the eve of the Harvest Fayre. Wanda Batton-Smythe, the draconian leader of the local W.I. is managing to make herself even more unpopular than normal to ensure that the Fayre, the jewel in her crown, goes off without a hitch. So come the day of the Fayre, everything is in place – various stalls, a fortune teller, competing food tents, a dead body… Oh, she didn’t plan on the last thing.

Enter the local vicar, Max Tudor, an ex-MI5 agent who has now found the solace that he needed in the parish. But his personal paradise being invaded by evil is not something he is going to let happen, and soon he finds himself investigating a mystery. After all, everybody hated Wanda… but did anyone hate her enough to find a devious way to murder her?

G M Malliet has written, to date, three “Death Of A…” mysteries featuring DCI St Just, and this is the first in a new series featuring ex-spy-turned-vicar Max Tudor. I was sent a copy by the publisher as it seemed to be the sort of thing that I would like… An optimistic move, I thought, as the publisher also publishes MC Beaton’s work, and we won’t say any more about my experiences there. But I needed an easy read… but is that what I got?

First of all, much better than Beaton. Light years ahead, in my humble opinion.

The spy-turned-vicar idea struck me as a little bizarre when reading the blurb, and, if it sets off alarm bells with you dear reader, do rest assured that it is one of the most effective bits of the book. The narrative of the mystery is interspersed with Max’s reminiscences of how he got to this point of his life and it gives an added dimension to an idea that on the face of it sounds a bit silly but it gives the lead character a lot more depth and humanity that a lot of detectives that I can think of.

The rest of the village gets a good airing too. I don’t know how many of them will re-appear in the next book (and therefore wiping them off the list of suspects if you read the series out of order) but all of them, including the killer, get some decent development. Also, plaudits for not making Max’s love-life a focal point of the plot. There is something brewing in that direction, but it’s a minor thing rather than a major distraction. Presumably this is going to develop over the books, but, again unlike some other series, it’s not at all obvious which way things will go.

The mystery? Well, it stumped me. I wouldn’t go as far as saying that it’s completely classically clued – in the finale, I’m not convinced that Max knew who was going to turn up in his trap – but it makes a lot of little things throughout the book make sense. I twigged the most important clue after the murderer had been revealed – I realised the relevance before Max explained it all – but I was fooled, good and proper. Yes, the killer’s plan is rather extreme – and the bit with the wig is an odd distraction – but it does make sense.

Niggles? There are a couple of points where the writer’s US roots betray her – a reference to someone’s grandmother having a recipe for candied yams, and a mention of zucchini (courgettes for people on this side of the pond) – but other than this, the portrayal of life in an English village is light enough to satisfy the cozy readers and with enough darkness at the edges for the reader who wants to see it.

Overall, this is an extremely well-crafted book and an enjoyable read. I’ll be looking out for more in the series, and the author’s previous work too. Highly Recommended.


It’s been out in the US for a while, and it’s already available as an ebook over here. The paperback is out in mid-July.


  1. I enjoyed this book a lot. I spotted the vital clue related to the cause of death immediately. It seemed rather obivous, in fact. But I do have a sensitivity to certain …uh… issues so maybe I had an upper hand. The ending was a bit of a surprise to me and for once I was not bothered by what seems to be a sort of detective novel skeleton in the closet. (Trying to be vague and not ruin anything here.) The finale made perfect sense though I know a couple of people who read this boko and thought it “insensitive.” Actually, I wish there more writers willing to buck the PC trend and show more villains of this type. I know an awful lot of them — maybe not so murderous but just as nasty and selfish.


    • I thought the darkness of the motivation was one of the things that lifted this out of the traditional cozy classification. Very well done, IMHO. And as for the skeleton, at least it wasn’t left until the big reveal before it was introduced – although it was left pretty late…


  2. I really enjoyed Malliet’s “Death of A…” series and it sounds like I definitely need to check into this one. I agree with you that Malliet is much better than Beaton.


  3. I didn’t love this book, but it *is* miles above the M. C. Beaton I’ve read. My main issue was that the book’s pacing went completely stagnant after the victim’s funeral… and although the ending has a few elements of brilliance, that motive is so damn boring. I appreciate that Malliet did something a bit different by making the killer a bit nastier than this type usually is, but the whole “it was for love!” crap is still there to sort-of redeem the character, which I really hate seeing. I do agree with John here, though — I wish more writers did stuff in this vein instead of the strictly-PC approach so many take. It’s really gotten insane just how scared writers seem to be of offending someone. For instance, I just found out yesterday that the word “blackboard” is not a nice word and should always be replaced with “chalkboard”. Just how paranoid are we???


  4. I enjoyed two of the “Death of a … ” series, but wasn’t sure about this one. Glad to see you liked it. I will definitely add it to my list.


  5. Thanks for introducing me to this new author. I am addicted to cozy mysteries…so much fun! I now have to catch up with the Death Of A series and will look forward getting to know the Vicar.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.