Mr Monk On Patrol by Lee Goldberg

Mr Monk On PatrolYou may have encountered Adrian Monk before. As played by Tony Shaloub on television for eight years, he’s the world’s greatest detective – a former San Francisco police detective who had a nervous breakdown after the murder of his wife, he now consults with the SFPD. Oh, and he has… some issues. He suffers from OCD and 312 phobias (which he has ranked in order).  But he is an amazing detective.

This novel is set after the series has finished. Adrian and his assistant, Natalie Teeger, are summoned to Summit, New Jersey, by an old friend who is now chief of police there, to help solve a crime spree. Needless to say, it isn’t long before there’s a dead body alongside the numerous burglaries to get to the bottom of. Of course, Adrian can only solve the mystery if he has time while he deals with the most dreadful crime he has ever encountered – a shop called “Poop”, where every item sold is made out of excrement…

Monk is another TV that I’ve never got round to reviewing  but it’s one that I absolutely love. The central performances – notably Tony Shaloub, Traylor Howard (Natalie) and Ted Levine (Captain Stottlemeyer) – clever mysteries (mostly howdunits rather than whodunits) and a good line in humour. But how does that translate to the written page?

Very well indeed – especially the characters and the humour. Lee Goldberg has written fifteen novels based on the Monk TV series and three episodes of the show itself, so by now – this is the thirteenth novel – he knows the characters well. This the first novel set after the end of the TV show, he also has a freer hand in shaking up the status quo, which he does by relocating Monk and Natalie and giving them both a career change by the halfway point of the book, as well as introducing a potential love interest for Monk. If this was set during the series, you would know the relationship would be doomed (and she’d probably be the murderer to boot) but here, those sort of assumptions can’t be made. The central characters of Monk and Natalie (the narrator) are caught perfectly, apart from the oddity of the narration repeatedly referring to Monk, rather than Mister Monk, but that would look odd as well.

And there’s the poop jokes. Lots of poop jokes. And they’re very funny poop jokes.

Heh. Poop.

The mystery – well, mysteries – are unfortunately a bit obvious. The first one – a whodunit – is hardly a surprise, given a dearth of suspects at that point, and the second – a howdunit – basically steals its method from one of the more important episodes of the TV series. But it’s told with charm and humour and, given I needed a distraction from more important matters when I was reading it, it was exactly what I needed at the time. It’s a lot of fun – as are the other books in the series that I’ve read – and if you’re a fan of the show, it’s Highly Recommended.



  1. I haven’t read the Monk books, but I’ve heard Lee Goldberg speak at a number of mystery conferences. He’s hilarious in person, and I’m pretty sure that translates well into the books.


  2. Having Natalie narrate is an excellent choice and Goldberg is very good at this sort of thing – thanks Steve, this is one of the few spin-off / tie-in publications that I would really consider getting.


    • Of the other books that I’ve read, I really enjoyed Mr Monk Goes To Hawaii, Mr Monk and the Blue Flu and Mr Monk and the Two Assistants (although bits of this are contradicted by the episode where Sharona returns). The only iffy one was Mr Monk Is Miserable, set in Paris.


    • I thought Monk never really resorted to the case of the week problem, partly because the ongoing story was so rarely touched on. Later on, they did seem to run out of ideas for the crime part of the story. I’ll have to start a rewatch/review of the series sometime.


Leave a Reply to Review Of The Year – 2014 | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.