Malice In Maggody by Joan Hess

Welcome to Maggody, Arkansas, the very definition of a small town in the middle of nowhere. A town that people want to leave but rarely do – due to a lack of ability or opportunity. A town where half the population have the same surname, a lot of people are… how shall we put it, closely related to one another, often in more than one way. Rather than a family tree, think of a family tangle.

Arly Hanks is one of the few people to leave who actually came back, as Sheriff of the town, although most of her duties are dealing with speeders and the occasional drunk. But when a local EPA officer vanishes on his way to deliver his report on local water quality, an escaped violent convict seems to be making his way back to town and a barmaid is killed with a crossbow, it looks like she’s going to have her hands full.

One of my personal challenges this year is to revisit some blog themes that have fallen by the wayside over the years and this ticks two boxes in that respect. One was to take a look at some of the US “cozy” genre again – you know the ones I mean – and one was to revisit the books of Joan Hess.

Joan Hess, who passed away in November 2017, was a prolific writer of mystery fiction, with twenty books in her Claire Malloy series – the first three, Strangled Prose, The Murder At The Murder At The Mimosa Inn and Dear Miss Demeanour, I reviewed three years ago – and sixteen books centred around Arly Hanks and Maggody, along with a few other bits and bobs. For example, she completed the final Elizabeth Peters Amelia Peabody mystery.

The Claire Malloy series was reprinted in the UK recently by Bello Books but I don’t think the Maggody books have had a paperback printing over here – they are available as ebooks but as surprisingly pricey ones – oddly, £6.02. Why the 2p? Presumably, it’s an exchange rate thing. Anyway, I got my copy from a second hand shop for £2 a couple of years ago…

It’s an odd book. Maggody doesn’t resonate as a place you’d want to visit – you can almost hear the duelling banjos in the background. You find yourself not quite believing that the author lived in that state, as this is about as convincing a reason to visit the place as David Mark’s books are to visit Hull. Also the main plot of the book – not a spoiler, as it occurs very early – is that the EPA guy is kidnapped by the town council, in a plan that generally seems stupider than the average episode of the Dukes Of Hazzard. The majority of the characters seem to have morals that range from dubious to bottom-of-the-sewer, with the exception of Arly and her presumably love-interest colleague. But what isn’t part of the main plot is the murder.

The murder almost seems levered in at the last minute, with the characters barely mentioning it until the finale, concerned with finding the EPA guy for most of the time. They don’t even know that the convict has shown up until late on, so you’d think a murder would take priority, no? And with point of view scenes from a good number of the cast, it’s clear that the two events, no matter how involved some characters were with the victim, as pretty unrelated.

But given that, the murder does have a good clue in it and a well-hidden murderer, and, at the end of the day, the book is an enjoyable enough read. I think I prefer the Claire Malloy series, as I prefer her sarcastic narration, but I wouldn’t be adverse to a return visit to this series at some point.

One thing though – despite the style of the book cover and the blurb, this may be funny (at times) but it’s not cozy. Sweary at times and with some fairly crude language concerning sex (from admittedly a fairly crude character), it might put some people off. It’s no Stuart MacBride, but even so.

So, you could do a lot worse than taking a look at this, but be clear what you’re getting – a backwoods crime romp (that isn’t quite as funny as it thinks it is) with a decent mystery short story being intermittently dealt with. Worth A Look.


    • Well, it’s refreshing free of a lot of the cozy cliches, such as very distinctive career that impinges in every investigation or a talking cat, and it’s got a nice line in wit, imho, but I guess it qualifies as a cozy. IIRC, the ones that I’ve read get “solved” when Claire trips over the killer doing something incriminating, so that seems to fit the bill for most cozies that I’ve read.


  1. “despite the style of the book cover and the blurb, this may be funny (at times) but it’s not cozy.”

    This book was first published in 1987, and I think the definition of ‘cozy’ has changed over time.

    Specifically, certain publishers have locked down a style of fiction with rules to cultivate a certain readership.

    Recently I was reading a 1993 book from a writer currently established as a ‘cozy author’. There was a scene where a family pet was murdered as a warning to the amateur sleuth to drop the investigation.

    Well, I was so shocked the book practically fell from my hands. Not only would such a scene never be published in any ‘cozy’ written in, say, the last 10 years, but an author who even submitted it would probably be blacklisted from the genre.

    Killing people, OK. Killing pets NO!

    So, 30 years ago different readers with different expectations.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.