The Puzzly – The ISOTCMN Novel Book Of The Month – June 2023

Tell me, dear reader, have you ever tried to create a timetable for a secondary school? No? Well, to give an idea of the complexity, imagine trying to complete eighty-one sudokus simultaneously where each sudoku is linked to every other one by having a cell in common. While sky-diving. Oh, and when you finally land with a solution in your hand, someone comes to you and tells you that the top right cell on sudoku fifty-six can’t be a 9 because that number can’t be next to the 8 in the adjacent cell. And then repeat about four or five times.

Anyway, that’s one reason why my reading this month has been down again – a mere seven books. Luckily, they were seven decent books, but hopefully, as I think the timetable is all-but-done, I can get down to some proper reading this month.

But seven books isn’t none, so of course I need to pick a book of the month. Is “need” the right word? Yes, yes it is.

The books in question were:

Fear Comes To Chalfont by Freeman Wills Crofts Not his best, but another example of why Crofts should not be overlooked as a top Golden Age writer.

After The Exhibition by Dolores Gordon-Smith Another outing for Jack Haldean in an exemplar of how to do a Golden Age pastiche from a master of the genre.

A Most Efficient Murder by Anthony Slayton And another decent Golden Age pastiche – the promising start of a series.

The Red House by Roz Watkins A well-crafted twisty thriller with a final chapter that completely wrong-footed me. It’s very dark though…

The Trial by Rob Rinder The latest celebrity to take up the mystery-writing gauntlet and probably the best yet. Rubbish cover though…

The Mill House Murders by Yukito Ajatsuji A clever Japanese classic mystery – if only it wasn’t so obvious…

Fearless by M W Craven A new series from the author, with an intriguing lead character. A real page-turner of a thriller. Thank goodness he got the physics right on page 238 though…

You know, depending on my mood, I could have chosen almost any of these. Even The Mill House Murders, despite everyone I know spotting the “who” very early on – not necessarily the “how” though… But it’s going to go to the book that I couldn’t put down. I was desperate to read and review it by publication date and thanks to Mr Timetable, I had about twenty-four hours. But I had faith based on prior experience and Mike Craven did not let me down. Fearless just drew me in as it went along. Ah, just realised what it was. I read another book recently with a protagonist with a different point of view from most people and basically, the reader was told about the differences from the beginning. Here, that aspect of the character is drip-fed, allowing the reader to think about it until things are made a little clearer by the narrator. It’s a really good character study – amid the guns, knives and blood…

So, congratulations to M W Craven for his umpteenth Puzzly – you know, I really should do a count on these at some point. Next month, we’ve got a somewhat dull Poirot to kick things off, an early (so hopefully good) Belton Cobb and then, who knows?

7 comments

  1. Whoop! ‘Master of the genre’! I’ll have to get bigger doors in the house so I can get my head through! I didn’t set out to write pastiches but just the sort of book I love to read. Now I’m off to download MV Craven…

    Like

    • Never fond of the word pastiche as it does seem to imply that you’re copying or aping something else, but I don’t have an alternative for books that could have been written at the time and would have sat comfortably in the higher echelons.

      As for Mike Craven, the Washington Poe series starting with The Puppet Show is a great place to start. There are a few gory bits, be warned, but it’s well worth it…

      Like

      • I’ve just bought his short story collection lured by the fact there’s a springer spaniel in at least one. I know, I know – it’s an odd reason to choose a book but spaniels are ace!

        Like

Leave a reply to Puzzle Doctor Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.