The Mari Lwyd is, to be fair, a strange festival. Just after Christmas, in Welsh towns, wassailers go from door to door… carrying a decorated horse skull. As you do. But this year, in the town of Ceigwyn, the festivities are a sideshow to the discovery of a dead body. Gwennie Jones was attacked and died from her injuries, but to Mallory Dawson, former police officer in the Met and current civilian police adviser, this seems to be something more than a basic assault.
Fourteen years previously, Gwennie’s aunt, Jaci, went missing in London. It was Mallory’s first case, and it was never solved. Jaci was never found, alive or dead, and it has preyed on Mallory all this time, not least because of accusations of police incompetence. Now she has an opportunity to set things right… especially if Gwennie’s death and Jaci’s disappearance are linked.
This is the fifth Mallory Dawson book from Sarah, who has currently has the Carla James Jericho series on the go at he moment. Two books a year, this is Golden Age author level or writing, and we can be glad about that, because Sarah is an excellent writer.
This series concerns Mallory who, in The Birthday Girl, was trying to find her place in the world, and by now, she’s basically found it. Well, there’s an issue as to how her relationship with DI Harri Evans is going to progress, but it’s more a question of speed rather than of stopping. It always proves to be a problem in series about troubled lead characters because eventually they sort them out, and then either live out a happy existence or have to be re-traumatised. I’m glad Sarah took the first option, as I like Mallory, but it did mean that the majority of the plot had to be held by the cold case mystery.
And it’s a perfectly enjoyable example of that genre. I’ll be honest, I was hoping for something a little more bizarre, but that’s not Sarah’s fault, it’s just because I’d previously read The Murders Of Christmas Past which is enjoyably bonkers. Any book was going to struggle in comparison with that one. So it’s to its strength that despite the normality of it, I still enjoyed this one.
The First Mistake is out now from Canelo Crime in paperback and ebook. Many thanks for the review copy.

